Code Review the UK Home Office Way: Friendly, Automated and Checklist-Driven
The UK Home Office guidance treats code review as part of the team workflow: allocated time within sprints, constructive feedback, automation support and a clear checklist.
This article was prepared with AI assistance from the official sources listed below, and checked automatically before publication.

Code review is often seen as an extra task done if there is time. As a result, code quality is uneven and knowledge accumulates in just a few people. In its "Code reviews" guidance page, labelled as updated on 10 April 2025, the Engineering Guidance and Standards team at the UK Home Office describes review as an important part of the software lifecycle. In their view, review maintains code quality while spreading knowledge among team members.
What This Practice Is
The page is tagged Software design and Ways of working. This means review is treated as a way of working for the team, not merely a technical step. There are five main principles:
- Part of the workflow. Time to review code is allocated within the sprint so that standards are maintained.
- Constructive and friendly. Focus on the code, not its author. Every developer has different ideas, so the reasons for a change need to be explained, not just feelings expressed.
- Point out what is good. Positive feedback helps build a healthy team culture.
- Pull request template. The template serves as a checklist for both the PR author and the reviewer.
- Automation. Tests and linters, such as ESLint and Prettier, are automated to lighten the review burden.
How It Works in Practice
The guidance stresses that the list of things to check is not exhaustive. Teams are encouraged to have their own standards, and the PR template becomes the place to capture them. Questions proposed by the Home Office include:
- Does it work as expected? Making sure of this prevents bugs and errors from reaching production.
- Is it tested? Check whether the existing tests pass, and suggest additional automation where needed.
- Is it easy to read? Readable code is easier to understand, refactor, maintain and debug.
- Is the design good? Look at error handling, logging, fit with the project, missed edge cases and potential performance issues.
- Is it protected from misuse? Look for code injection vulnerabilities, unvalidated user input and personal data (PII) in error messages.
- Does it take existing code into account? Make sure developers reuse functions available in the framework, tools and team standards.
- Is it documented? Ask whether the documentation would be sufficient if you were to work on the code yourself later.
- Does it follow standards? This includes team standards, SEGAS standards and UK government service manual standards.
- Do the regular expressions make sense? These expressions are hard to read and write, so test them and think about edge cases not yet covered.
Pitfalls to Watch For
- Personal reviews. Comments that attack the author rather than explaining technical reasons damage team culture.
- Highlighting only shortcomings. The guidance asks that good things be pointed out too.
- Review without time. If it is not allocated within the sprint, review is easily pushed aside.
- Manual work that can be automated. Checking code style manually drains reviewers' energy.
- AI-generated code. The Home Office asks reviewers to be extra vigilant because AI does not know the team's shared functions or services, so the code may duplicate what already exists.
- Treating the list as final. The list is only a recommendation, not a replacement for team standards.
How Teams and Clients Can Apply It
Development teams can start with something simple: draft a PR template containing the checklist above, then adapt it to internal standards. Enable automated tests and linters so that reviewers can focus on logic, design and security.
For IT managers and public-sector officials who use vendor services, this practice can serve as a basis for discussion: is review time allocated within sprints, is there an agreed checklist, and how is code produced by AI assistants reviewed. The emphasis on input validation and PII in error messages is also relevant to personal data protection needs, although the Home Office guidance itself does not discuss Indonesian regulations.
The key message is simple: friendly, automated, checklist-guided review makes quality a team habit, not a coincidence.
Sources & references
This article is a summary and interpretation by the Oemah Solution team of the sources below. Refer to the original sources for full details and context.

